An holl danevelloù
lostcities_displayed danevelloù bog
#16390: "Display individual round scoring at end of each round and at end of game"
acknowledged: An diorroerien a soñj dezho ez eo ur mennozh a-feson ha fellout a ra dezho stagañ ganti
What is this report about?
Petra a zo c'hoarvezet ? Trugarez evit dibab amañ dindan
Kinnig : d'am soñj e c'hellfe kement-se gwellaat a galz emplementadur ar c'hoari
Deskrivadur dre ar munud
• Displegit ho kinnig mar-plij, e berrgomzoù met en un doare resis, evit ma vefe an aesañ posupl kompren mat ar pezh ho peus c'hoant lâret.
At the end of each round, it would be nice if the points that each player gained /during that round/ were displayed in the log.
Furthermore, at the end of the game, it would also be nice if a summary were displayed showing the points gained/lost by each player over the three rounds. Something like this:
R1 || R2 || R3 || Final
Player 1 +20 || -14 || +58 || 64
Player 2 -13 || +45 || -16 || 6• Peseurt merdeer eo hoc'h hini ?
Google Chrome v81
Roll-istor an danevelloù bog
28. Ebr 2020 11:03 • bananasplay • This suggestion has not been analyzed by delopers yet:
Thanks for considering this idea!
28. Ebr 2020 16:25 • bmcfluff • This suggestion has not been analyzed by delopers yet:
I'm ambivalent about this; I'll do it if there are enough votes - let's say 7 votes in 2 months and I'll definitely do it, but maybe with fewer/longer too depending on how I'm feeling. I get notifications on comments but not votes, so please comment if you're the 7th voter :)
15. Mae 2020 14:15 • BigJ • This suggestion has not been analyzed by delopers yet:
It has 7 votes now. I think this would be particularly helpful for new players to help them understand how scoring works. It's nice for experienced players too though. I hope you will expose the math that is already being done. Thanks!
15. Mae 2020 15:55 • bmcfluff • An diorroerien a soñj dezho ez eo ur mennozh a-feson ha fellout a ra dezho stagañ ganti:
Ok, I guess I'm doing this :) (not sure exactly how long it will take...)
18. Mae 2020 0:39 • bmcfluff • An diorroerien a soñj dezho ez eo ur mennozh a-feson ha fellout a ra dezho stagañ ganti:
Update on this: code is written, but because it involves a change to what is stored in the game's database (individual round scores were never stored before), it would break games in progress. Thus we need to wait until a site admin can handle this (including blocking the game for a while), and unfortunately all admins are super busy these days with higher priority things (probably because of the usage spike thanks to the pandemic). I could do a stop-gap partial version which could be deployed without admin assistance, but I think that's more trouble than it's worth.
19. Eos 2020 13:40 • bananasplay • An diorroerien a soñj dezho ez eo ur mennozh a-feson ha fellout a ra dezho stagañ ganti:
Regardless of whenever this comes around to being put into effect, please accept my thanks now for implementing it. :-)
19. Eos 2020 16:57 • bmcfluff • An diorroerien a soñj dezho ez eo ur mennozh a-feson ha fellout a ra dezho stagañ ganti:
Thanks! I was inspired by BigJ's comment to expose not only previous round scores but also all the math behind the current round's score, and to make this available at any time rather than just end of round. I think it will be a great tool for new players and you will like how it turned out :)
I'll go ping the admins again since it's been a while; it's possible there's still a priority backlog and we'll have to wait but it's also possible they just forgot. And maybe keep the upvotes coming so they know we should be on that priority list too :)
I'll go ping the admins again since it's been a while; it's possible there's still a priority backlog and we'll have to wait but it's also possible they just forgot. And maybe keep the upvotes coming so they know we should be on that priority list too :)
19. Eos 2020 18:46 • bmcfluff • An diorroerien a soñj dezho ez eo ur mennozh a-feson ha fellout a ra dezho stagañ ganti:
Admin response was that it'll still be a while; the admin team will be growing in September so hopefully they'll be able to get through the backlog faster after that.
27. Her 2020 20:31 • EllenCaroline • An diorroerien a soñj dezho ez eo ur mennozh a-feson ha fellout a ra dezho stagañ ganti:
I wish I could see the end game results of each round before the cards are wiped away and a new round started. Sometimes I think I'm ahead, but the cards disappear too quickly to be sure.
10. Eos 2021 18:45 • BigJ • An diorroerien a soñj dezho ez eo ur mennozh a-feson ha fellout a ra dezho stagañ ganti:
What is the update on this? I played with a friend today and it was his first time. I took pictures w/ my phone and marked them up to help explain end of round scoring. Thanks for your hard work. I appreciate having this game and the work you've done on it!
13. Eos 2021 16:24 • bmcfluff • An diorroerien a soñj dezho ez eo ur mennozh a-feson ha fellout a ra dezho stagañ ganti:
@BigJ: Admins just got back to me and requested some changes to reduce the impact on games in progress; I'll do it but don't have time for at least a month
21. Gwe 2021 22:01 • Emerald13 • An diorroerien a soñj dezho ez eo ur mennozh a-feson ha fellout a ra dezho stagañ ganti:
If we could also have a breakdown of the scores from each color between rounds and a confirmation that we would like to move to the next round, instead of the next round being dealt immediately, that would be great!! =)
25. Gen 2023 16:04 • Mioranduh • An diorroerien a soñj dezho ez eo ur mennozh a-feson ha fellout a ra dezho stagañ ganti:
Yes, totally agree. It would be great if the scoring would be similar as to how the (in between) scoring Jaipur works. Every round you get shown a table with the score.
it would be great if it would be split in the colours as well. And for which one you get the bonus points, the start minus 20 removed, etc.
it would be great if it would be split in the colours as well. And for which one you get the bonus points, the start minus 20 removed, etc.
5. Cʼhw 2023 19:02 • juliagulia915 • An diorroerien a soñj dezho ez eo ur mennozh a-feson ha fellout a ra dezho stagañ ganti:
Hi, looks like adding the scoring at the end of each round is going on three years in the making. Would definitely help me and my friends maintain interest in the game if we could see the score breakdown like other games do.
5. Cʼhw 2023 19:35 • bmcfluff • An diorroerien a soñj dezho ez eo ur mennozh a-feson ha fellout a ra dezho stagañ ganti:
Hi julia,
I am as frustrated as you are; I wrote the code for this over a year ago and as far as I can tell it does exactly what you want, but the BGA admins have not responded to my last three emails requesting the code be shipped. I've given up at this point, but you are welcome to try other ways to catch their attention and maybe it will help.
I am as frustrated as you are; I wrote the code for this over a year ago and as far as I can tell it does exactly what you want, but the BGA admins have not responded to my last three emails requesting the code be shipped. I've given up at this point, but you are welcome to try other ways to catch their attention and maybe it will help.
23. Eos 2024 16:32 • SquashEngineer • An diorroerien a soñj dezho ez eo ur mennozh a-feson ha fellout a ra dezho stagañ ganti:
I'm a recently new player to Lost Cities, Wanted to check it out here before potential purchase. All indications are that I am loving it.
The suggested Scoring table at end of round and end of game seem essential in this digital version, and as a newb player, would very much appreciate seeing how the overall Score is compiled: both from the standpoint of early learning of the game and strategy, but also long term for score verification (which seems to be an issue seeing the other bug submissions).
I understand it appears as if the developer has already created the software mods required for this improvement, however that implementation is stalled.
Any chance we can lift up the priority on this overdue, and highly sought, improvement, for a popular game?
The suggested Scoring table at end of round and end of game seem essential in this digital version, and as a newb player, would very much appreciate seeing how the overall Score is compiled: both from the standpoint of early learning of the game and strategy, but also long term for score verification (which seems to be an issue seeing the other bug submissions).
I understand it appears as if the developer has already created the software mods required for this improvement, however that implementation is stalled.
Any chance we can lift up the priority on this overdue, and highly sought, improvement, for a popular game?
Ouzhpennañ un dra bennak d'an danevell-mañ
Ouzhpennit amañ mar-plij, tout ar pezh a c'hellfe bezañ talvoudus evit ma c'hellfemp dreveziñ ar bog-mañ pe kompren ho kinnig:
- Niverenn taol all / Niverenn ar fiñv
- Ha renket eo bet ar gudenn gant an douchenn F5 ?
- Ha c'hoarvezet eo ar gudenn meur a wech ? Bewech ? Cheñch-dicheñch ?
- M'ho peus un dapadenn skramm eus ar gudenn (ho pezit soñj d'eus se !), gellout a rit implij Imgur.com evit e bellgargañ hag eilañ/pegañ al liamm amañ.
