Danevell • Board Game Arena

An holl danevelloù

thecrew_displayed danevelloù bog

#23802: "Show discard pile"

implemented: K

?

thecrew #111051893

Petra a zo c'hoarvezet ? Trugarez evit dibab amañ dindan

Kinnig : d'am soñj e c'hellfe kement-se gwellaat a galz emplementadur ar c'hoari

Petra a zo c'hoarvezet ? Trugarez evit dibab amañ dindan

Kinnig : d'am soñj e c'hellfe kement-se gwellaat a galz emplementadur ar c'hoari

Gwiriit mar-plij ma n'eus ket dija un danevell evit an hevelep dodenn

M'oc'h a-du, VOTIT evit an danevell-mañ. An danevelloù gant ar muiañ a vouezhioù a vo studiet DA GENTAÑ !

#	Status	Votes	Game	Type	Title	Last update

Deskrivadur dre ar munud

Roll-istor an danevelloù bog

8. Sep 2020 11:02 • qqzm • K:

8. Sep 2020 20:44 • crj • K:

Having upvoted this, I've noticed the rules are explicit that only the most recent trick may be inspected.

Therefore, if this is implemented, it should be a configurable option.

8. Sep 2020 21:48 • Pompkin • K:

I think it should at least be an option for asynchronous play

9. Sep 2020 19:35 • phyphor • K:

I suspect that the rules are to prevent the game jamming up rather than to make the game explicitly a memory one. The log shows what has been played, and people can write things down, it's just a matter of making what's already public knowledge more visible and clear.

It's not really any different from the way that BGA has implemented the knowledge gained in Hanabi, for example.

4. Oct 2020 04:24 • Remi_R • K:

I think the current development is already quite wrong regarding the original rules. To implement this option will make the game still more easy which means it will decrease the interest of it.
The goal of cooperative game is to create some struggle for the team. If everything is eased... then what is the interest to play it ?

11. Oct 2020 01:30 • Romain672 • K:

@Remi_R: You can already do it by checking the logs.
Some player like to have no memory aspect (like in hanabi) which let us goes more deep into strategy.

It's not remove all things which make the team struggle, it's remove the things which don't add anything into the strategy.

11. Oct 2020 01:31 • Romain672 • K:

It could be done with another circle in the green 'square' which, when you put the mouse on it, display the card missing.

17. Oct 2020 18:35 • Matthijs Kooijman • K:

Even if the log was modified to not show the tricks other than the most recent one (which would be more correct per the rules, though maybe not possible), players could still just write down things (though one could argue that this is also against the rules) or just remember it in their head (that can't really be against the rules)?

Maybe this could be a table option (i.e. house rule), though? As a play group, you either allow looking back through previous tricks (and then also facilitate this by making a easy-to-review discard pile, rather than having to look back through the log), or you decide to play by the rules strictly and not show the discard pile (and, if possible, maybe also remove all but the last trick from the log)?

18. Oct 2020 20:23 • A-Town Bob • K:

This goes against the rules, see page 4 on the left side bar.

Tricks that are won are placed face down; only the last trick can be looked at.

18. Oct 2020 20:28 • A-Town Bob • K:

After reading more of the comments, I would like to point out that "remember" what has and has not been played is a basic track taking thing. It is called card counting and most trick taking games work this same way. Part of the game is leaning how to count cards and what cards to count. Bridge, Pinochle, Hearts, Spades, all require you to learn how to count cards.

20. Oct 2020 12:31 • qqzm • K:

I think the easiest way to solve this issue is as Matthijs Kooijman suggests - have an option when setting-up the game:
1) No information - no discard pile, no logs.
2) Full information - tricks shown in the log and also a sorted discard pile that you can examine.

10. Dec 2020 22:00 • Supergravity • K:

As an avid Bridge and Spades and Hearts player, my take is that card counting is part of the skill of the game, and looking back in the log is akin to cheating. So I am definitely against showing the discards in an organized way.

13. Jan 2021 16:02 • qqzm • K:

I've created a browser extension for Chrome and Firefox that addresses this issue, see: boardgamearena.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=293&t=19177

3. Apr 2021 08:00 • Ludo Dave • K:

Make it an option to see the discards in a table. It's trackable information, and many game groups treat all trackable information as open information, even when the official rules say to keep the info hidden.

3. May 2021 19:01 • EpicDim • K:

I love all the people that talk about card counting is the secret. Try playing multiple Turn based games where you only make one play every couple of days. A single hand can last a week or two.

My group having an option doesn't hurt your group choosing not to play with it. The ELO is non sensical for this game, so let us play in a way that we will enjoy more.

16. Jun 2021 14:34 • Tisaac • K:

Implemented.

Ouzhpennañ un dra bennak d'an danevell-mañ

Ouzhpennit amañ mar-plij, tout ar pezh a c'hellfe bezañ talvoudus evit ma c'hellfemp dreveziñ ar bog-mañ pe kompren ho kinnig:

Niverenn taol all / Niverenn ar fiñv
Ha renket eo bet ar gudenn gant an douchenn F5 ?
Ha c'hoarvezet eo ar gudenn meur a wech ? Bewech ? Cheñch-dicheñch ?
M'ho peus un dapadenn skramm eus ar gudenn (ho pezit soñj d'eus se !), gellout a rit implij Imgur.com evit e bellgargañ hag eilañ/pegañ al liamm amañ.

nullañ Hizivaat an danevell

#23802: "Show discard pile"

?

Petra a zo c'hoarvezet ? Trugarez evit dibab amañ dindan

Petra a zo c'hoarvezet ? Trugarez evit dibab amañ dindan

Gwiriit mar-plij ma n'eus ket dija un danevell evit an hevelep dodenn

Deskrivadur dre ar munud

Roll-istor an danevelloù bog

Ouzhpennañ un dra bennak d'an danevell-mañ

Cheñch statud an danevell e :

Skoazell

Kemer perzh

Navigate

Heuliit ac'hanomp